Considered and left out

Trails and routes that were looked at for this dataset and left out, and why.

This page lists 45 trails and routes that were considered for this dataset and left out, with the reason, the deciding fact and the date for each one. Every one of them is a good walk in its own right and was left out only because it does not meet the rule this list uses, and 16 of them were listed here once and later removed. If the facts behind a decision have changed, open an issue and give a page that shows the change, and the decision will be looked at again.

Below the 50 mile floor

The floor for this list is 50 miles (80 km), apart from a few well known shorter trails.

TrailWhereLengthWhy it is left outDecidedSource
Black Forest TrailPennsylvania42 mi68 km

Pennsylvania DCNR give this loop in Tiadaghton State Forest as 42.1 miles. That is below the 50 mile floor.

Source page
Chuck Keiper Trail
Once listed here
Pennsylvania47 mi76 km

The Keystone Trails Association say the trail consists of a main loop of 47.3 miles, with a cross-connector of 3.3 miles. The main loop is below the 50 mile floor.

Source page
Fundy Footpath
Once listed here
New Brunswick26 mi41 km

This Fundy Hiking Trail Association trail along the Bay of Fundy coast is 41 km long. That is below the floor for this list.

Source page
Greenstone Ridge TrailMichigan42 mi67 km

The National Park Service give this Isle Royale trail as about 41.7 miles. That is below the 50 mile floor.

Source page
Lake Superior Coastal TrailOntario40 mi65 km

Ontario Parks list this Lake Superior Provincial Park backpacking trail at 65 km. That is below the floor for this list.

Source page
Mantario TrailManitoba40 mi64 km

Manitoba Parks describe it as extending over 60 kilometres through the Mantario Wilderness Zone of Whiteshell Provincial Park. At about 64 km it is below the floor for this list.

Source page
Rachel Carson TrailPennsylvania46.2 mi74.4 km

The Rachel Carson Trails Conservancy give it as 46.2 miles between Harrison Hills County Park and Wexford. That is below the 50 mile floor.

Source page
Trans-Catalina TrailCalifornia38 mi62 km

The Catalina Island Conservancy give it as 38.5 miles of trail across the island. That is below the 50 mile floor.

Source page
Uwharrie TrailNorth Carolina40 mi64 km

The Forest Service describe a 40 mile trail in Uwharrie National Forest. That is below the 50 mile floor.

Source page

Rail trails and canal towpaths

Paths made mainly for cycling, such as gravel rail trails and canal towpaths, are not listed.

TrailWhereLengthWhy it is left outDecidedSource
Chesapeake and Ohio Canal Towpath
Once listed here
Maryland, District of Columbia, West Virginia184 mi297 km

The National Park Service describe 184.5 miles of canal towpath along the Potomac River. It is a canal towpath, which the rule leaves out.

Source page
Confederation TrailPrince Edward Island170 mi273 km

Tourism Prince Edward Island say the former island railway became this trail after rail service ended in 1989, 273 km from tip to tip and 449 km with the branch trails. It is a rail trail, which the rule leaves out.

Source page
Florida Keys Overseas Heritage TrailFloridaA planned 106 mile corridor, with more than 90 miles paved

Florida State Parks describe it as a multi-use bicycle and pedestrian resource that incorporates 23 of the historic Flagler Railroad bridges. It is paved in segments along the corridor from Key Largo to Key West, with more than 90 miles of trail on a planned 106 mile corridor.

Source page
George S. Mickelson TrailSouth Dakota109 mi175 km

South Dakota Game, Fish and Parks say the trail is 109 miles of crushed limestone with more than 100 converted railroad bridges. It is a rail trail, which the rule leaves out.

Source page
Great Allegheny PassagePennsylvania, Maryland150 mi241 km

Its conservancy describe a 150 mile path between Pittsburgh and Cumberland on a former rail corridor with a crushed limestone surface. It is a rail trail, which the rule leaves out.

Source page
Katy TrailMissouri240 mi386 km

Missouri State Parks call it the longest developed rail trail in the country, 240 miles on the former Missouri-Kansas-Texas Railroad corridor. Rail trails are left out by the rule.

Source page
Kettle Valley Rail TrailBritish Columbia410 mi660 km

The City of Penticton visitor page describes 660 km from Hope to Castlegar as a decommissioned railway converted into a recreational rail trail. Rail trails are left out by the rule.

Source page

Mainly driving or motor routes

Historic trails that are mainly driving routes with short walkable pieces are not listed.

TrailWhereLengthWhy it is left outDecidedSource
Great Western Trail
Once listed here
Arizona, Utah, Idaho, Wyoming, Montana3,100 mi4,989 km

The Forest Service call it a 3,100 mile corridor of parallel trails and dirt roads for motorized and nonmotorized users. On the North Kaibab section they say hiking and horse use are not recommended because the route is on open roads.

Source page
Iditarod National Historic Trail
Once listed here
Alaska1,000 miles main route, with about 1,400 miles of side and connecting trails

The Bureau of Land Management call it the only winter trail in the National Trails System, a 1,000 mile main route between Seward and Nome with about 1,400 miles of side and connecting routes. It is travelled in winter by dog sled and snowmachine, not as a walking trail.

Source page
Nez Perce National Historic Trail
Once listed here
Oregon, Idaho, Montana, Wyoming1,170 mi1,883 km

The Forest Service publish this 1,170 mile historic route chiefly as eight auto tour segments on roads between its sites. There is no continuous walking trail to record.

Source page
Overmountain Victory National Historic Trail
Once listed here
Virginia, Tennessee, North Carolina, South Carolina330 mi531 km

The National Park Service say the 330 mile route can be followed on a commemorative motor route along existing state highways, or on a little over 80 miles of walkable trail in pieces. Mainly a driving route, it is left out by the rule.

Source page

Mainly for bikes, horses or motor vehicles

A trail made mainly for other users is not a walking trail for this list.

TrailWhereLengthWhy it is left outDecidedSource
Crow Wing TrailManitoba124 mi200 km

Its association call it a 200 km section of the Trans Canada Trail from Winnipeg to Emerson along an old Red River cart trail. They promote it for cycling and horseback riding as well as hiking, and much of it follows gravel municipal roads.

Source page
High Rockies TrailAlberta50 mi80 km

Alberta Parks give it as 80.0 km from Goat Creek to Elk Pass and list it among their hiker and biker trails, with camping for hikers and cyclists. It is presented mainly as a ride rather than as a walking trail.

Source page
Highline National Recreation Trail (Bear River Range)Idaho60 mi97 km

The Forest Service list this Bear River Range trail at 60 miles and list motorcycle trail riding among its uses. A trail open to motorcycles does not meet the rule for a walking trail.

Source page
Metolius-Windigo TrailOregon120 mi193 km

This 120 mile Deschutes National Forest trail was built mainly as a long distance horse trail, served by horse camps along the way. Hikers and mountain bikers may use it, but it was not built mainly as a walking trail.

Source page
Rainbow TrailColoradoOver 100 miles

The Forest Service say this trail of over 100 miles along the Sangre de Cristo Range is open to motorcycles, mountain bikers, horse and foot traffic. A trail open to motorcycles for its whole length does not meet the rule.

Source page
Sea to Sky TrailBritish Columbia112 mi180 km

The Squamish-Lillooet Regional District call it a non motorized multi use trail of 180 km, open for hiking and biking, with some sections designed for adaptive mountain biking. It is made mainly for shared use with bikes rather than as a walking trail.

Source page

Networks, not one trail

This list holds one named trail or route at a time, not a whole network of trails.

TrailWhereLengthWhy it is left outDecidedSource
Bonneville Shoreline TrailUtahMore than 280 miles proposed; just over 100 miles designated

Its committee say the trail will one day run more than 280 miles, from the Idaho border to Nephi, and that just over 100 miles are now officially designated. Those designated miles are separate segments along the proposed route, not one continuous walk.

Source page
Potomac Heritage National Scenic Trail
Once listed here
District of Columbia, Maryland, Virginia, PennsylvaniaA network of over 900 miles

The National Park Service describe it as a network of trails stretching over 900 miles. They publish no single route to walk from end to end.

Source page
Sentiers de l'EstrieQuebecMore than 200 km of trails

The club publish more than 200 km of forest walking trails in separate sectors in the Estrie hills. That is a network of trails, not one trail.

Source page
Trans Canada Trail
Once listed here
All provinces and territories18,641 mi30,000 km

Trans Canada Trail call it a 30,000 kilometre network connecting coast to coast to coast, for activities from hiking and cycling to paddling and snowmobiling. A network of local trails is not one trail under the rule.

Source page

Cannot be walked through

A listed trail can be walked as one continuous walk, road links allowed.

TrailWhereLengthWhy it is left outDecidedSource
Bay Area Ridge Trail
Once listed here
California550 miles planned for the loop; over 400 miles open

The Ridge Trail Council say there are two continuous stretches, and that otherwise there are still gaps in the trail. It names no connecting routes through the gaps, and its circumnavigation means walking every dedicated section in any order.

Source page
Buffalo River TrailArkansas37 miles and a little more than 42 miles, in two separate sections

The National Park Service publish it as two separate hikes, a 37 mile upper section from Boxley Valley to Pruitt and a little more than 42 miles from Woolum to Dillards Ferry. No trail was built between Pruitt and Woolum, so the two sections cannot be walked as one trail.

Source page
Cumberland Trail
Once listed here
TennesseeOver 300 miles planned; 208.9 miles completed

The Friends of the Cumberland Trail say that once completed the trail will extend over 300 miles, and that 208.9 miles are completed. About 90 miles are not built and no connecting routes are published, so it cannot be walked from end to end.

Source page
Iron Belle Trail
Once listed here
Michigan1,273 miles planned for the hiking route; more than 70 percent complete

The Michigan Department of Natural Resources say the trail is currently more than 70 percent complete. The rest of the 1,273 mile hiking route is only mapped as proposed, with no connecting routes or through guide published.

Source page
Natchez Trace National Scenic Trail
Once listed here
Mississippi, Alabama, TennesseeFive separate sections, over 60 miles in all; the longest is 26 miles

The National Park Service say the trail consists of five separate sections, over 60 miles in all. The longest, Yockanookany, is 26 miles, so no one walk from end to end exists.

Source page
Palmetto Trail
Once listed here
South Carolina500 miles when complete; about 400 miles open in passages

The Palmetto Conservation Foundation say it will span 500 miles when complete, and publish about 400 miles as separate passages. There is no way across the gap between Columbia and Peak or across the Tyger River, and no through route is published.

Source page
Sentier National
Once listed here
QuebecAbout 1,830 km, in separate sections

Rando Quebec give the trail as 1,830 km long, in nine regional sections, and publish no continuous route to walk from end to end.

Source page
Trans-Zion TrekUtah48.3 mi77.7 km

At about 48 miles it is below the floor to begin with. The National Park Service also list the East Rim Trail, part of the walk across Zion, as a long term closure since a 2019 rockfall, so it cannot now be walked through.

Source page
Voyageur Trail
Once listed here
OntarioAbout 1,100 km planned; built as separate sections

The association's vision is to build a continuous wilderness hiking trail from Sudbury through Sault Ste. Marie to Thunder Bay, some 1,100 km. Today it is separate sections kept by seven clubs, with no continuous route to walk.

Source page

Not published as a route by its author

A route is listed when its author has published it as a route, with a stated length.

TrailWhereLengthWhy it is left outDecidedSource
Grand Escalante LoopUtah

Its author presents it as a long hike he made around Escalante, with a map of the trip. No page of his publishes it as a route for others to follow with a stated route length, so there is no published route to record.

Source page
Grand GulchUtah

The Bureau of Land Management publish Grand Gulch as a canyon in a Wilderness Study Area, reached by separate short access trails, and state no through length. No land manager publishes it as a named walk with a length.

Source page

Waiting

Not left out for good. Each entry says what would change the decision.

TrailWhereLengthWhy it is left outDecidedSource
Alaska Long TrailAlaska500 mi805 km

The Bureau of Land Management is studying a proposed 500 mile route from Seward to Fairbanks made of existing and proposed trails. It is not yet one designated trail.

It would be listed if this changes: It is designated a National Scenic Trail.

Source page
American Perimeter Trailcontiguous United States14,000 mi22,531 km

Its own page calls it a 14,000 mile trail system around the contiguous United States and says it uses existing trails, off trail treks, thoroughfares and some undefined routes. The page also says the mileage will change as the trail is developed.

It would be listed if this changes: Every part of the route is defined and published, with a settled length.

Source page
Pine Mountain State Scenic TrailKentucky120 miles planned

Kentucky state this linear state park is still under development, to run 120 miles from Breaks Interstate Park to Cumberland Gap when complete. They put the designated trail at two sections totalling 44 miles, from Breaks to US 119.

It would be listed if this changes: The built trail reaches 50 miles in one continuous piece, or the whole planned trail can be walked through.

Source page
xTexas TrailTexas1,500 mi2,414 km

Its association say they are creating a 1,500 mile trail across rural Texas for hikers, cyclists and horseback riders, and its first end to end hike was in early 2026. Much of it is on rural roads and the route is still being changed.

It would be listed if this changes: The association publish the route in a settled form that is no longer being rerouted.

Source page